Step 1 of 4

Clarify the arrangement

A babysitting agency might introduce a sitter, employ staff or handle bookings and replacements. Ask which role it takes and who receives your payment. In-home babysitting is a different arrangement from care offered to multiple families at another home. Read Ontario’s descriptions of childcare arrangements if you are comparing the two.

Step 2 of 4

Check fit for your child

Discuss experience with children of the same age and with any tasks the sitter will actually perform. Ask for references they have permission to share and time to speak with them. If an agency advertises screening or first-aid training, ask what it checks, when and how it confirms the person arriving at your door. A background check is only one part of choosing someone you trust.

Step 3 of 4

Plan the first handover

  • Introduce the sitter to the child and show them exits, the home address, emergency phone access and household boundaries.
  • Give the essential routine, allergies or specific care instructions privately. Agree on who can collect the child.
  • Discuss meals, bedtime, transport, screen use, photos and whether anybody else may visit.
  • Agree on a check-in, a backup contact and what happens if you return late.

Example message: “We need care at our home in Vaughan on Friday from 6 to 9 p.m. for a four-year-old. Could we meet the assigned sitter first? What is the full charge, and what happens if that sitter becomes unavailable?”

If the agency proposes a replacement, ask for the same introduction and screening information. For regular full-day care or care in someone else’s home, investigate Ontario’s licensed childcare options separately.

Step 4 of 4

Speak with a reference about a specific booking

With the sitter’s and reference’s permission, ask how old the children were, which responsibilities the sitter handled and how they communicated about a change of plan. A reference from someone who employed the sitter for an after-school pickup may tell you little about caring for a baby at bedtime. Ask the sitter how they would handle the routine you need and arrange a first visit where you can observe the introduction. Discuss any differences in advance rather than leaving an unfamiliar household rule to be discovered during a booking.

Related question · What should you ask a babysitting agency about screening and cancellations?