Build a vehicle and driver sheet
Collect the year, make, model, trim and vehicle identification number if available. Include whether you own, lease or finance it, where it is normally parked, estimated kilometres, all regular drivers and how you use it. A commute, occasional recreation and paid delivery work can present different risks. If you are still shopping, ask for an estimate on the exact model before committing to the purchase.
Record first licence dates and places, policy history, claims, tickets and any gaps accurately. The date Ontario issued your local licence may differ from the date you first became licensed. Ask whether the insurer accepts a foreign driving record or claims-experience letter, who must issue it and whether a translation is needed. Wait for that answer before ordering paid records. FSRA guidance on shopping for auto insurance.
Understand the coverage choices
Read FSRA’s standard Ontario auto policy guide. Third-party liability concerns harm or damage for which you are legally responsible. Accident benefits deal with specified benefits following injury. Coverage for damage to your own car depends on the applicable policy section, including choices such as collision or comprehensive coverage. Ask how any deductible or opt-out affects a particular crash or loss.
Ontario changed its statutory accident benefit rules on July 1, 2026. Medical, rehabilitation and attendant care accident benefits remain mandatory. Other accident benefits became optional. Ask your broker or insurer to identify the optional benefits included in each quote and what applies to each person in your household. A lower premium may reflect a different selection. FSRA’s July 2026 accident benefit changes.
Request like-for-like quotes
- Set one comparison date, vehicle, address, use and driver list. If an insurer assumes a different commute, correct it before comparing.
- Put liability limits, each accident benefit, collision and comprehensive deductibles, rental replacement and other add-ons on separate lines.
- Ask whether monthly instalments add a fee, which discounts depend on continued participation and what financing or lease conditions require.
- Identify any history document pending and ask whether the current quote assumes it will be accepted.
Review a plausible claim
Real-life example
Your car is stolen and you need transport to work. Ask what the policy would pay under its theft coverage, what deductible applies and whether replacement transportation is included. Now ask how the same quote responds if a person in the household is injured and cannot work. These are different coverage questions. Keep the insurer’s written explanation with the quote.
Confirm the effective date and time and obtain the insurance evidence required before taking the car on the road. For an Ontario broker, check RIBO’s broker search. Use the driving history questions when requesting records from abroad.
If one premium changes after the first call
Ask the insurer to identify which input changed: documented experience, listed drivers, vehicle use, address or the coverage selection. Obtain the revised quote and update only those rows. If both price and protection changed, ask for the original coverage with the corrected facts. This gives you a clean basis for deciding whether it is the underwriting assumption or the policy choice that explains the difference.
