Build two versions of the same move
Use the same inventory, pickup and destination for each option. For a truck, record the rental period, distance allowance, extra-distance rate, fuel arrangement, pickup and return locations and any equipment. Check driver and licence requirements directly with the rental company. Include the time needed to collect and return the vehicle, not only the journey between homes.
Account for labour and access
Who will pack, lift, carry, secure, unload and reassemble the items? Confirm that the available people and equipment suit the job rather than assuming friends can manage every item. Check elevator bookings, stairs, parking and loading access. A move that needs several journeys or cannot fit the booked access window can change both cost and practicality.
Compare the responsibility for problems
Ask each provider how damage, delays, cancellations and claims are handled. Do not assume your existing insurance or a card benefit covers the vehicle, belongings and activities involved. Compare the actual terms and ask the relevant insurer about uncertainty. The Office of Consumer Affairs moving checklist provides useful questions for the broader move.
Add a time estimate beside the money
Hypothetical example: a $90 rental can become a $230 transport cost after distance, fuel and equipment, before any paid help. That may still fit your move, but it is not a $90 alternative to a complete service. Use the quote worksheet for entered costs and keep a separate list of work and risks you would handle yourself. Choose only after both versions describe a feasible completed move.
For the broader decision, read How to rent a van or moving truck in Ontario.
