Set the same use and time horizon
Write down your approximate monthly kilometres, where the vehicle is parked and how long you expect to keep it. Ask for insurance quotes using the actual vehicles and the same coverage limits and drivers. FSRA explains the information insurers may use to prepare a quote. FSRA auto insurance quote guidance
Include the regular payment schedule for a lease or loan. Convert biweekly payments by multiplying by 26 and dividing by 12. Put the down payment and expected end-of-term charge or buyout in the longer-term comparison. If you pay cash, track the upfront requirement and estimate the change in resale value over your ownership period. OMVIC’s buying guidance covers loan and purchase decisions. OMVIC guide to buying a vehicle
Put irregular expenses into the same budget
Example using hypothetical figures: A $350 payment, $190 insurance, $120 fuel and $65 parking total $725 a month. Setting aside $600 annually for servicing adds $50 per month, making $775 before other costs. Add repairs, tires, plates where applicable, tolls and any winter tire storage. When you compare two cars, keep the mileage and parking assumptions consistent.
Check what happens to the budget if insurance is higher, a parking space comes with a fee, or one repair arrives soon after purchase. Use the transport cost worksheet to compare with other ways of making the same trips.
Read the full guide for more detail. Buy or lease a car in Ontario: what to compare.
